Table 5.6. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for COL Data Set.
DATA SET: COL
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 100
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
72.00
1.249
1.4127
68.00
1.144
1.5363
COLBY
2
62.00
1.004
0.8986
ENGELUND-HANSEN
1
50.00
0.851
1.1833
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
3
ACKERS-WHITE, D50
49.00
0.700
0.8543
BROWNLIE, D50
48.00
0.704
0.8256
ACKERS-WHITE.
44.00
0.672
0.8588
TOFFALETI-MPM
39.00
0.624
0.7591
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSCH
39.00
0.614
0.7486
YANG.
38.00
0.472
0.6868
YANG, D50
38.00
0.503
0.6802
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
32.00
0.595
0.7617
VAN RIJN
31.00
0.518
0.9252
TOFFALETI.
29.00
0.502
0.7606
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
27.00
0.587
0.8892
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
14.00
0.298
0.7617
SCHOKLITSCH
2.00
0.123
0.8885
MPM(1948).
2.00
0.136
0.8771
MPM(1948),D50
2.00
0.159
0.8575
PARKER
0.00
0.000
1.0050
Table 5.7. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for HII Data Set.
DATA SET: HII
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 38
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
YANG.
94.74
1.290
0.5404
86.84
1.219
0.6851
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
2
ENGELUND-HANSEN
84.21
1.246
0.6062
81.58
1.225
0.6691
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
3
78.95
0.815
0.4836
TOFFALETI-MPM
1
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
73.68
1.586
1.0890
ACKERS-WHITE,D50
68.42
0.667
0.4901
ACKERS-WHITE.
68.42
0.623
0.4999
VAN.RIJN
65.79
0.898
0.7972
YANG,D50
63.16
1.806
1.0598
BROWNLIE,D50
52.63
0.513
0.5586
MPM(1948),D50
52.63
0.661
0.5770
MPM(1948).
50.00
0.535
0.6076
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
44.74
2.500
2.1361
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSC
42.11
1.512
1.4665
COLBY
42.11
0.571
0.8030
SCHOKLITSCH
42.11
1.230
1.2945
TOFFALETI.
28.95
0.338
0.7500
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
26.32
0.370
0.7345
PARKER
13.16
0.258
0.8996
67
Chapter 5
Theoretical Basis for SAM.aid
Previous Page
