Table 5.2. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for ACP Data Set.
DATA SET: ACP
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 142
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
TOFFALETI-MPM
57.04
1.343
1.2863
56.34
1.222
1.2112
TOFFALETI.
3
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSCH
55.63
1.305
1.2650
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
54.93
1.567
1.7284
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
54.23
1.716
1.6165
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
53.52
1.440
1.7098
50.70
0.830
0.7461
ACKERS-WHITE.
2
ACKERS-WHITE, D50
49.30
0.859
0.7996
45.77
1.019
0.9600
ENGELUND-HANSEN
1
BROWNLIE, D50
44.37
0.812
0.7816
VAN RIJN
41.55
0.731
0.8370
COLBY
40.14
1.456
1.6258
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
37.32
1.405
1.9642
YANG, D50
31.69
0.445
0.7005
YANG.
26.76
0.416
0.7059
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
21.13
0.370
0.8619
MPM(1948),D50
5.63
0.158
0.8590
MPM(1948).
2.11
0.137
0.8759
SCHOKLITSCH
0.70
0.094
0.9140
PARKER
0.00
0.000
1.0035
Table 5.3. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for AMC Data Set.
DATA SET: AMC
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 11
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
45.45
1.092
1.2213
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
1
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
45.45
0.462
0.6777
BROWNLIE, D50
27.27
0.309
0.7708
27.27
0.690
0.8809
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
3
ENGELUND-HANSEN
27.27
0.434
0.6877
ACKERS-WHITE, D50
27.27
0.294
0.7822
COLBY
27.27
0.370
0.7592
ACKERS-WHITE.
27.27
0.283
0.7858
27.27
0.741
1.2944
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
2
TOFFALETI.
18.18
0.455
0.8375
YANG.
18.18
0.270
0.8012
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
18.18
0.230
0.8374
VAN RIJN
18.18
0.359
0.7513
TOFFALETI-MPM
18.18
0.579
0.7908
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSCH
18.18
0.490
0.8215
YANG, D50
18.18
0.265
0.8115
MPM(1948),D50
9.09
0.175
0.8835
SCHOKLITSCH
0.00
0.041
1.0068
MPM(1948).
0.00
0.150
0.9008
PARKER
0.00
0.001
1.0473
65
Chapter 5
Theoretical Basis for SAM.aid
Previous Page
