Table 5.14. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for NSR Data Set.
DATA SET: NSR
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 55
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
58.18
1.475
1.6476
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
1
56.36
2.317
2.8571
SCHOKLITSCH
3
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSCH
56.36
2.384
2.8983
50.91
1.703
2.0211
BROWNLIE, D50
2
VAN RIJN
47.27
0.950
0.8668
ACKERS-WHITE.
43.64
3.268
5.9799
ACKERS-WHITE, D50
34.55
3.806
7.4862
PARKER
27.27
6.603
13.3796
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
21.82
6.493
11.2715
YANG.
21.82
6.255
10.2682
YANG, D50
20.00
9.118
15.4717
MPM(1948),D50
14.55
6.661
12.1554
MPM(1948).
9.09
7.636
11.1704
TOFFALETI-MPM
9.09
7.712
11.2263
TOFFALETI.
7.27
0.161
0.8634
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
1.82
13.757
18.6927
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
1.82
13.762
18.6946
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
1.82
20.655
26.6636
COLBY
0.00
0.000
1.0092
ENGELUND-HANSEN
0.00
21.050
28.2610
Table 5.15. Sediment Transport Function Rankings for OAK Data Set.
DATA SET: OAK
# DATA POINTS
IN SET: 17
Percent of data points
Average Standard
Standard Deviation of
FUNCTION
in discrepancy ratio
deviation of Discrepancy
Discrepancy Ratio
range
Ratio
41.18
1.081
1.0122
LAURSEN(MADDEN),1985
1
ACKERS-WHITE.
29.41
0.373
0.8095
TOFFALETI.
29.41
0.850
0.9430
29.41
1.142
2.0338
YANG.
2
17.65
0.862
1.3960
BROWNLIE, D50
3
MPM(1948),D50
5.88
2.651
5.7522
PROFITT(SUTHERLAND)
5.88
0.136
0.9356
PARKER
0.00
185.278
274.7783
VAN RIJN
0.00
181.225
326.1328
SCHOKLITSCH
0.00
56.861
79.6337
ENGELUND-HANSEN
0.00
89.682
119.9400
EINSTEIN(BED-LOAD)
0.00
25.277
33.3275
ACKERS-WHITE, D50
0.00
0.000
1.0308
TOFFALETI-SCHOKLITSCH
0.00
57.585
80.6903
COLBY
0.00
0.000
1.0308
EINSTEIN(TOTAL-LOAD)
0.00
25.301
33.3628
MPM(1948).
0.00
27.752
40.5980
YANG, D50
0.00
0.019
1.0141
LAURSEN(COPELAND)
0.00
108.222
160.7211
TOFFALETI-MPM
0.00
28.486
41.5653
71
Chapter 5
Theoretical Basis for SAM.aid
Previous Page
