Table 10.4. Bank Migration for Alternative 4.
Return Period
Discharge
Bank Migration
Design Buffer
(yrs)
(cfs)
Distance (ft)
Strip Distance* (ft)
50
51,600
562
1,124
100
62,000
629
1,258
200
72,500
715
1,430
*The eroded bank should be restored to its present alignment after each flood to maintain an
adequate buffer zone.
Alternative 5. The fifth alternative is to construct a series of rock riprap spurs to guide the flow
away from the existing north bank (Figure 10.9). The design of the spurs includes: the form of
spurs, the angle of spurs to the bank, the length of spurs, the spacing between spurs, the
height or elevation of spurs, the construction materials, the crest width and slopes, and the
local scour. The design of the spurs is summarized in Tables 10.5, 10.6, and 10.7. Table 10.5
gives a summary of spur designs for different design floods including buffer strip distance,
number of spurs, spacing of spurs, height of spur above the existing thalweg level, riprap size
at the spur nose, and riprap size in the spur shank. Table 10.6 provides the suggested design
dimension of spurs including spur form, spur length, angle of spur to bank, the portion requiring
riprap the same size as used on the nose, and length requiring shank protection. Table 10.7
summarizes the sizes of riprap and filter design at the nose of the spurs and for the spur
shanks. HEC-23 (Lagasse et al. 2001) also provides design guidelines for a typical round nose
spur recommended by FHWA.
Table 10.5. Summary of Spur Design.
T
Q
Bm
Sd
Ns
ha
l
n
s
hb
K 50
K 50
yrs
cfs
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
50
51,600
1,250
7
600
12.5
10.0
1.1
0.6
100
62,000
1,250
7
600
13.5
11.0
1.3
0.7
200
72,500
1,250
7
600
14.5
12.0
1.4
0.7
Note:
T is the flood return period in years, Q is the design discharge, Bm is the minimum buffer strip distance between the
railroad and the spur nose, Ns is the number of spurs, Sd is the spur spacing, ha is the design height of spur above the
l
n
existing thalweg level, hb is the design depth of spur at the spur nose below the existing thalweg level, K 50 is the
s
median size of riprap at the spur nose, and K 50 is the size of riprap for the spur shank.
Table 10.6. Dimension of Spurs.
Length
Length
Spur
Spur
Spur
T-Nose
Angle of
Requiring
Requiring
No.
Form
Length
Length
Spur to Bank
Nose Riprap
Shank
()
(ft)
(ft)
Size (ft)
Protection (ft)
1
T-nose
200
400
90
20
180
2
T-nose
200
400
90
20
180
3
Round nose
500
N/A
70
200
300
4
Round nose
750
N/A
70
200
550
5
Round nose
750
N/A
70
200
550
6
Round nose
400
N/A
70
200
200
7
Round nose
200
N/A
70
200
0
10.14