example, a bridge with foundations in clay that is to be replaced in a few years. However, as

Briaud et al. (1999) point out the ultimate scour in cohesive material is as deep as in sand bed

material.

Jones (1983) compared many of the more common equations. His comparison of these

equations is given in Figures 7.3 and 7.4. Some of the equations have velocity as a variable

(normally in the form of a Froude number). However, some equations, such as Laursen's, do

not include velocity. A Froude number of 0.3 was used (Fr = 0.3) in Figure 7.3 for purposes of

comparing commonly used scour equations. In Figure 7.4, the equations are compared with

some field data measurements. As can be seen from Figure 7.4 the CSU equation encloses

all the data points, but gives lower values of scour than the other equations. The CSU

equation includes the velocity of the flow just upstream of the pier by including the Froude

Number in the equation.

The equations illustrated in Figures 7.3 and 7.4 do not take into account the possibility that

larger sizes in the bed material could armor the scour hole. That is, the large sizes in the bed

material will at some depth of scour limit the scour depth. FHWA's HEC-18 scour depth

equation has a coefficient, which is applied to the CSU equation, that decreases the scour

depth when the bed material has large particles.

Mueller (1996) compared 22 scour equations using field data collected by the USGS

(Landers and Mueller 1996; Landers, Mueller, and Richardson 1999). He concluded that the

HEC-18 equation was good for design because it rarely under predicted measured scour

depth. However, it frequently over predicted the observed scour. The data contained 384

measurements of scour at 56 bridges. Figure 7.5 gives six of his 22 comparisons. The six

equations in Figure 7.5 are Shen's, Froehlich's, Laursen's, Melville and Sutherland's, HEC-

18, and Mueller's modified HEC-18 equation (HEC-18BM).

The Colorado State University's Equation (Richardson et al. 1975) is as follows:

0.65

a

ys

Fr10.43

= 2.0 K 1 K 2

(7.6)

y1

y1

where:

ys

=

Scour depth, m (ft)

y1

=

Flow depth just upstream of the pier, m (ft)

K1

=

Correction for pier shape from Table 7.1 and Figure 7.6

K2

=

Correction for flow angle of attack of flow from Table 7.2 and Equation 7.8

a

=

Pier width, m (ft)

Froude number = V1 / (gy1) 0.5

Fr1

=

V1

=

Velocity upstream of pier, m/s (ft/s)

7.13

Technology News |

Qualcomm Intros World's Most Powerful LTE ModemQualcomm goes to 11 ... no, 12. Snapdragon 820 X12... eetimes.com Cunning Chronograph: One Ring vs. Three Rings?Determining the optimum approach to driving multiple NeoPixel rings --... eetimes.com Skyworks to Buy PMC-Sierra for $2 BillionDeal to "create an analog and mixed-signal powerhouse" set to... eetimes.com US proposes nearly $2 million fine against drone operatorThe U.S. Federal Aviation Administration on Tuesday proposed a record... phys.org Apple Acquires Perceptio, A Deep Learning, AI SpecialistIn the quest to create an ever-smarter iPhone, Apple has... eetimes.com M'soft Attacks Apple with Win 10Microsoft unveiled new Surface, Lumia and Microsoft Band devices on... eetimes.com From trees to power: Engineers build better energy storage deviceNew work demonstrates an improved three-dimensional energy storage device constructed... sciencedaily.com Cadence DSP Promises More Horsepower for Next-Gen SmartphonesNext-generation Tensilica vision and imaging DSP promises up to 13X... eetimes.com Silicon Europe Grows to Cover 12 RegionsThe Silicon Europe project - set up in 2012 to... eetimes.com Makerarm Multifunction Robotic Arm -- A Maker's Dream!Want a complete digital fabrication system for makers everywhere: 3D... eetimes.com Back to the future with nature's own construction materials?Europe's construction industry has a crucial role in cutting carbon... phys.org ITS: Car OEMs See Role as Service ProvidersCarmakers have been great at playing two cards -- "Safety"... eetimes.com Video: Moderating extremes in building designLeon Glicksman designs buildings with an eye toward improved energy... phys.org Panel PC with flat screen has 4GB memoryAdvantech's TPC-1751T is a 17-in. flat screen panel PC with... ocreg.controleng.com India Can Triple CO2 Emissions Under New Climate CommitmentPresident Obama received another commitment from a developing country last... instituteforenergyresearch.org India’s Commitment to Climate Change Allows Carbon Dioxide Emissions to TriplePresident Obama received another commitment from a developing country last... instituteforenergyresearch.org T&M Survey: The Age of Today's EngineersAn EE Times/EDN survey shows that a high percentage of... eetimes.com |

Integrated Publishing, Inc.
9438 US Hwy 19N #311
Port Richey, FL 34668
Phone For Parts Inquiries: (727) 755-3260 Google + |